Countries:
Russia
Topics:
Freedom of Speech, Cyber-Activism, Governance, History, Human Rights, Law, Literature, Media, Technology, Politics
Languages:
Russian

This post is also available in:

pt:
Rússia: Blogueiro é julgado por escrever ficção...

Dmitry Shirinkin (a Perm-based LJ user tetraox) faces trial for having written on his blog that he had purchased a gun and was going to kill a few dozen people in one of the city’s colleges.

According to Shirinkin, the text - posted on April 21, but made private on April 22 - was a work of fiction, “inspired” by the Virginia Tech shooting. According to the prosecutor's office, however, Shirinkin has violated Article 207 of the Russian Criminal Code by “distributing false information on a planned terrorist act.” The trial is likely to take place in September; if convicted, the Russian blogger may receive a three-year prison sentence.

A concerned reader (LJ user rassty) asks (RUS) Shirinkin:

I wonder how the LJ community is going to keep you from being destroyed? And by the way, do you have a good lawyer - or a court-appointed one?

Shirinkin replies:

The lawyer's good, an old friend, a colleague from the legal community. Experienced, respected. Has been working at this particular court a lot.

[…]

There's no way for LJ to help me. LJ is a virtual thing, unfortunately( I'll have to work it out on my own(

Anton Nossik - LJ user dolboeb, a representative of the company that oversees LiveJournal's Russian segment - is not too optimistic (RUS) about the direction that Vladimir Putin's Russia is moving in:

[…] Though, of course, it's good that it is all still happening in Perm, not in Moscow. But [the Commander's footsteps] are getting louder.

LJ user pavel_kireev, in a comment to Anton Nossik's post, writes that the government is beginning to tighten the screws on Russia's internet users:

How good I felt on the web in 2001… In 2003, I felt safe but knew that it wasn't going to last. And now, freedom has ended…

LJ user denbor argues (RUS) the details of Shirinkin's case with LJ user zemsky, also in the comments section of Nossik's post:

denbor:

You've confused the terms. He's not being tried for LJ. LJ is nothing but a technical means through which he distributed false information on a terrorist act in the making. This is what real freedom is about. He was free to do what he did, and the prosecution was free to apply legal means to him. Why is everyone so upset? The law enforcement officials have not violated any laws. Any clever lawyer would tell you that they were using the article appropriately. All within the legal framework. […]

zemsky:

Only a mass medium can be used to distribute information. A newspaper, for example. Or a phone call. And it was clear right away that this was a work of fiction. And it wasn't the author who distributed false information, but that other person, the one who had turned him in. […]

denbor:

Quote: “And LJ is a tool for expressing all kinds of nonsense.”

An interesting definition. But it appears that we'll have to get used to the idea that the internet is also a mass medium, and the one that's even more efficient than TV, radio or newspapers […]. […] And he hasn't been imprisoned yet, right? His case is just being considered in court. If he proves that this was nothing but a work of fiction, great. The main thing is to get the people to understand that they will be held responsible for their words. Unfortunately, people in Russia aren't used to this - or have gotten unused in the 15 years of anarchy.

Anton Nossik concludes (RUS):

The main thing is to get the people to understand that they will be held responsible for their words. Unfortunately, people in Russia aren't used to this - or have gotten unused in the 15 years of anarchy.

Priceless words.

We've spent 15 years without censorship, without Criminal Code articles for “anti-Soviet agitation” and “distributing false information that defames the regime.”

Now we're getting back there.

And of course, there are those who like it.

The only thing that's not clear is why they were sitting online, waiting for this event, instead of appealing to the North Korean embassy, asking for political asylum.

8 Responses to
“Russia: Blogger on Trial for Writing Fiction”

  1. Latimeri:
    1

    Is it work of fiction or not somewhere must be draw the limit.

  2. Bob Sankofa:
    2

    That ‘work’ is very scary. We’ve heard stories of college students killing people in America only to come to find that they once disclosed that they were going to do the damage. The sad thing is people come to know of that when the damage is no longer undone.

    This blogger deserves to stand before the court and given a chance to explain what he was actually thinking when he was writing. Justice is all he needs.

  3. Russian LiveJournal blogger could face three-year sentence at Global Voices Advocacy:
    3

    [...] 23-year old Russian blogger, Dmitry Shirinkin, who wrote a fiction story on his blog inspired by the Virginia Tech shooting, could face up to three years in prison (Please read the [...]

  4. Global Voices Online » Russian LiveJournal blogger could face three-year sentence:
    4

    [...] 23-year old Russian blogger, Dmitry Shirinkin, who wrote a fiction story on his blog inspired by the Virginia Tech shooting, could face up to three years in prison. In an interview [...]

  5. Global Voices Online » Free Speech Roundup: Turkey, Russia, Pakistan, India:
    5

    [...] 23-year old Russian blogger, Dmitry Shirinkin, who posted a fictional story on his blog inspired by the Virginia Tech shooting, could face up to three years in prison (read the whole [...]

  6. Mohammad:
    6

    It is sad that writers are ending up on trial for writing fiction, while governments responsible in part for genocides are evading justice.

    Here is an interview with Florence Hartmann, former official spokesperson for the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) at the Hague:

    http://srebrenica-genocide.blogspot.com/2007/09/great-powers-srebrenica-genocide.html

    Sad reality…

  7. Global Voices بالعربية » الأرشيف » موجز مقالات عن حريّة التعبير: تركيّا, روسيا, باكستان والهند:
    7

    [...] [إنكليزي], ثلاث وعشرون سنة, حكم السجن لثلاث سنوات إثر نشره رواية على مدوّنته ألهمته بها حادثة جامعة فيرجينيا تيك (إقرأي المقالة [...]

  8. Dmitri:
    8

    I have read some of Dmitri’s work and it is a very sad state of affairs indeed.
    We need more freedom of speech…much more.

Join the conversation

Please consider
  • Comments on Global Voices are moderated.
  • If your comment does not appear immediately, there is no need to submit it again.
  • Please treat others with respect.
  • Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Funders
Sponsors
Korea content
supported by
OutBlaze Japan content
supported by
SanrioTown